diff --git a/web/cashtab/src/components/Home/Tx.js b/web/cashtab/src/components/Home/Tx.js
--- a/web/cashtab/src/components/Home/Tx.js
+++ b/web/cashtab/src/components/Home/Tx.js
@@ -873,14 +873,11 @@
                                                         </>
                                                     )}
                                                     {(!data.outgoingTx &&
-                                                        data.replyAddress &&
-                                                        addressesInContactList.includes(
-                                                            data.replyAddress,
-                                                        )) ||
-                                                    (!cashtabSettings.hideMessagesFromUnknownSenders &&
+                                                        data.replyAddress) ||
+                                                    (cashtabSettings.hideMessagesFromUnknownSenders &&
+                                                        displayedMessage &&
                                                         !data.outgoingTx &&
-                                                        data.replyAddress &&
-                                                        displayedMessage) ? (
+                                                        data.replyAddress) ? (
                                                         <Link
                                                             to={{
                                                                 pathname: `/send`,