diff --git a/doc/README.md b/doc/README.md --- a/doc/README.md +++ b/doc/README.md @@ -101,6 +101,7 @@ - [Tor Support](tor.md) - [Init Scripts (systemd/upstart/openrc)](init.md) - [ZMQ](zmq.md) +- [PSBT support](psbt.md) License --------------------- diff --git a/doc/psbt.md b/doc/psbt.md new file mode 100644 --- /dev/null +++ b/doc/psbt.md @@ -0,0 +1,132 @@ +# PSBT Howto for Bitcoin ABC + +Since Bitcoin ABC v0.20.7, an RPC interface exists for Partially Signed Bitcoin +Transactions (PSBTs, as specified in +[BIP 174](https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0174.mediawiki)). + +This document describes the overall workflow for producing signed transactions +through the use of PSBT, and the specific RPC commands used in typical +scenarios. + +## PSBT in general + +PSBT is an interchange format for Bitcoin transactions that are not fully signed +yet, together with relevant metadata to help entities work towards signing it. +It is intended to simplify workflows where multiple parties need to cooperate to +produce a transaction. Examples include hardware wallets, multisig setups, and +[CoinJoin](https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=279249) transactions. + +### Overall workflow + +Overall, the construction of a fully signed Bitcoin transaction goes through the +following steps: + +- A **Creator** proposes a particular transaction to be created. They construct + a PSBT that contains certain inputs and outputs, but no additional metadata. +- For each input, an **Updater** adds information about the UTXOs being spent by + the transaction to the PSBT. They also add information about the scripts and + public keys involved in each of the inputs (and possibly outputs) of the PSBT. +- **Signers** inspect the transaction and its metadata to decide whether they + agree with the transaction. They can use amount information from the UTXOs + to assess the values and fees involved. If they agree, they produce a + partial signature for the inputs for which they have relevant key(s). +- A **Finalizer** is run for each input to convert the partial signatures and + possibly script information into a final `scriptSig` and/or `scriptWitness`. +- An **Extractor** produces a valid Bitcoin transaction (in network format) + from a PSBT for which all inputs are finalized. + +Generally, each of the above (excluding Creator and Extractor) will simply +add more and more data to a particular PSBT, until all inputs are fully signed. +In a naive workflow, they all have to operate sequentially, passing the PSBT +from one to the next, until the Extractor can convert it to a real transaction. +In order to permit parallel operation, **Combiners** can be employed which merge +metadata from different PSBTs for the same unsigned transaction. + +The names above in bold are the names of the roles defined in BIP174. They're +useful in understanding the underlying steps, but in practice, software and +hardware implementations will typically implement multiple roles simultaneously. + +## PSBT in Bitcoin ABC + +### RPCs + +- **`converttopsbt` (Creator)** is a utility RPC that converts an + unsigned raw transaction to PSBT format. It ignores existing signatures. +- **`createpsbt` (Creator)** is a utility RPC that takes a list of inputs and + outputs and converts them to a PSBT with no additional information. It is + equivalent to calling `createrawtransaction` followed by `converttopsbt`. +- **`walletcreatefundedpsbt` (Creator, Updater)** is a wallet RPC that creates a + PSBT with the specified inputs and outputs, adds additional inputs and change + to it to balance it out, and adds relevant metadata. In particular, for inputs + that the wallet knows about (counting towards its normal or watch-only + balance), UTXO information will be added. For outputs and inputs with UTXO + information present, key and script information will be added which the wallet + knows about. It is equivalent to running `createrawtransaction`, followed by + `fundrawtransaction`, and `converttopsbt`. +- **`walletprocesspsbt` (Updater, Signer, Finalizer)** is a wallet RPC that takes as + input a PSBT, adds UTXO, key, and script data to inputs and outputs that miss + it, and optionally signs inputs. Where possible it also finalizes the partial + signatures. +- **`finalizepsbt` (Finalizer, Extractor)** is a utility RPC that finalizes any + partial signatures, and if all inputs are finalized, converts the result to a + fully signed transaction which can be broadcast with `sendrawtransaction`. +- **`combinepsbt` (Combiner)** is a utility RPC that implements a Combiner. It + can be used at any point in the workflow to merge information added to + different versions of the same PSBT. In particular it is useful to combine the + output of multiple Updaters or Signers. +- **`decodepsbt`** is a diagnostic utility RPC which will show all information in + a PSBT in human-readable form, as well as compute its eventual fee if known. + +### Workflows + +#### Multisig with multiple Bitcoin ABC instances + +Alice, Bob, and Carol want to create a 2-of-3 multisig address. They're all using +Bitcoin ABC. We assume their wallets only contain the multisig funds. In case +they also have a personal wallet, this can be accomplished through the +multiwallet feature - possibly resulting in a need to add `-rpcwallet=name` to +the command line in case `bitcoin-cli` is used. + +Setup: +- All three call `getnewaddress` to create a new address; call these addresses + *Aalice*, *Abob*, and *Acarol*. +- All three call `getaddressinfo "X"`, with *X* their respective address, and + remember the corresponding public keys. Call these public keys *Kalice*, + *Kbob*, and *Kcarol*. +- All three now run `addmultisigaddress 2 ["Kalice","Kbob","Kcarol"]` to teach + their wallet about the multisig script. Call the address produced by this + command *Amulti*. They may be required to explicitly specify the same + addresstype option each, to avoid constructing different versions due to + differences in configuration. +- They also run `importaddress "Amulti" "" false` to make their wallets treat + payments to *Amulti* as contributing to the watch-only balance. +- Others can verify the produced address by running + `createmultisig 2 ["Kalice","Kbob","Kcarol"]`, and expecting *Amulti* as + output. Again, it may be necessary to explicitly specify the addresstype + in order to get a result that matches. This command won't enable them to + initiate transactions later, however. +- They can now give out *Amulti* as address others can pay to. + +Later, when *V* BCH has been received on *Amulti*, and Bob and Carol want to +move the coins in their entirety to address *Asend*, with no change. Alice +does not need to be involved. +- One of them - let's assume Carol here - initiates the creation. She runs + `walletcreatefundedpsbt [] {"Asend":V} 0 {"subtractFeeFromOutputs":[0], "includeWatching":true}`. + We call the resulting PSBT *P*. *P* does not contain any signatures. +- Carol needs to sign the transaction herself. In order to do so, she runs + `walletprocesspsbt "P"`, and gives the resulting PSBT *P2* to Bob. +- Bob inspects the PSBT using `decodepsbt "P2"` to determine if the transaction + has indeed just the expected input, and an output to *Asend*, and the fee is + reasonable. If he agrees, he calls `walletprocesspsbt "P2"` to sign. The + resulting PSBT *P3* contains both Carol's and Bob's signature. +- Now anyone can call `finalizepsbt "P3"` to extract a fully signed transaction + *T*. +- Finally anyone can broadcast the transaction using `sendrawtransaction "T"`. + +In case there are more signers, it may be advantageous to let them all sign in +parallel, rather than passing the PSBT from one signer to the next one. In the +above example this would translate to Carol handing a copy of *P* to each signer +separately. They can then all invoke `walletprocesspsbt "P"`, and end up with +their individually-signed PSBT structures. They then all send those back to +Carol (or anyone) who can combine them using `combinepsbt`. The last two steps +(`finalizepsbt` and `sendrawtransaction`) remain unchanged.